Log in

No account? Create an account
entries friends calendar profile Previous Previous Next Next
Just thinking... Bill - Gryffindor yes, but what if he isn't a true… - Keeper of the Cages
Just thinking...

Bill - Gryffindor yes, but what if he isn't a true Gryf? I get this thing that he is slightly Slytherin too. Or he at least likes his Slytherins!

Any thoughts ideas?

Still don't think Bill/Fleur is right. Though in some weird way I do. Does that make sense???? That it's right but wrong at the same time?

Current Mood: contemplative contemplative

11 comments or Leave a comment
From: hunting_orc Date: August 4th, 2005 03:56 am (UTC) (Link)
at least he likes his WHAT?

i really don't like phlegm. HOWEVER it was all supposed to show that she really did love him no matter what, no? which is admirable.

jazzbandmusic From: jazzbandmusic Date: August 4th, 2005 01:08 pm (UTC) (Link)
Well him and Snape is rather a hot pic in my mind. And you know Harry isn't a complete Lion and so when you get him and Harry together they do produce a very good pic Mmmm. But to make it better you need a Harry/Bill/Sev 3sum. Hotttt and dangerous!

I think him and Severus do get on though. Don't ask me how or why I can't place it!

Yes I know she does love him and it's truely admirable, but still he deserves a young sneakylion!
From: hunting_orc Date: August 4th, 2005 08:06 pm (UTC) (Link)
oh. gross.

there's nothing except fanfiction that'd put bill with severus. come on! i can perhaps accept harry/random weasley because that's pretty. but WHY would sev have anything to do with them? he never stayed for dinner!!!
jazzbandmusic From: jazzbandmusic Date: August 4th, 2005 08:42 pm (UTC) (Link)
You do amuse me you know!

Yeah ok so not Severus, but you must admit that Harry/Bill is a good thing. Harry needs an older man to look after him.

Reasons for Sev...

1. Boy Who Lived - appeals to Slytherin side of going with the power. If can control then if the war goes to the light side he has Harry's protection and if it goes to the dark side he can keep Harry as a pet (so long as he survives)

2. Challenge - tame the wild Gryffindor. (and his hair!)

3. Revenge - What would James/Sirius have to say?!

4. Bill - he's intelligent, he's got to know a lot about magic both dark and light being a curse breaker.

5. He's not strictly a Gryffindor, or is open to other sides too.

I could go on, but I know you with your age-gappy thing wont take them! lol!

Bill's not that different in age from Sev anyway.
From: hunting_orc Date: August 4th, 2005 09:07 pm (UTC) (Link)
HOW is Bill not strictly a Gryffindor? He was, so why would he not still have those values?

No, but see, Sev's like 36-ish and Bill's more like 20-something. Which isn't as bad. And Bill's pretty, and I'd have him. But I really just don't see the Severus thing.
jazzbandmusic From: jazzbandmusic Date: August 5th, 2005 11:54 am (UTC) (Link)
I didn't say he wasn't a Gryffindor I just said he could have Slytherin in him. Most people do you know and I don't think he lets any Gryffindor reclesness out (must) so he's more restrained. I don't know I think he's more a Harry than a Ron. I'm not making sense but I'm not saying he isn't a Gryffindor. And I don't think he has lost any of his values.

Ok so it's not Cannon, but well Cannon is cannon and the rest is up to the pretty little minds that play!
From: hunting_orc Date: August 5th, 2005 08:02 pm (UTC) (Link)
Canon is a beautiful thing, but I think Bill/Tonks would've worked better. Even though it would've been too obvious...

No, that doesn't make sense... houses are picked by the type of person... so I don't think you can say people have a certain amount of 'Slytherin' because what is that? Not all Slytherins are murdering deatheaters, you know? It just says they're cunning... just like Gryffindors are brave but it doesn't mean they're good necessarily... hmm.
jazzbandmusic From: jazzbandmusic Date: August 5th, 2005 10:54 pm (UTC) (Link)
I do like canon, so many different avenues! I was rooting for Bill/Tonks the whole way through HBP - so very annoying! It's like several people have said we read canon because we want to see where JKR is taking her characters and we want to see the outcome (but not too soon!) Fandom is for changing things we may not like in JKR world and making the characters do what we want. Fandom is not a replacement for Canon it is a place for people to explore the different ways things could go under fans imaginations. Like what was all that rubbish about H/Hr shippers bemoaning the death of fandom? Hello Canon is real fandom is make believe (yes I do know its true!)

I know not all Slytherins are murdering deatheaters and I do think it's a shame to label the whole house with out even bothering to look at it closer. And yes the same can be said for Gryffindors not all are good they can just as easily be bad. Anyone from any house can be good or bad but the majority are going to be in the middle grey area where they are neither good or bad but a mixture.

Yes but Harry is a prime example the hat didn't really know which until Harry chose. Yes it is our choices that define us in the end, but still doesn't mean Bill can't be as cunning as a Slytherin nor as brave as a Gryffindor.
From: hunting_orc Date: August 5th, 2005 11:44 pm (UTC) (Link)
But... yeah, I never really understood that. Because I don't think that, had Harry shook hands with Draco, he would've been anywhere near as bad as Draco went on to be. He's too loyal to his friends, teen-angst aside, and he does the right thing in the end. I think Draco's too spineless to have gone anywhere near any of the stuff that Harry's done, and which Harry would still have done regardless of his house... I don't think there was really any question of him being in Slytherin. He didn't want to be the bullied that became the bully - in my opinion, anyway.

Randomly speaking of bullies, that bit pre-dementor with Dudley is one of my favourite scenes in OOTP. He stands up for himself! I love that it's his power, not his size that wins out. And he doesn't really abuse it... well, he abuses the threat of power to avoid the Dursley behaviour... but he could have been so much more f-ed up, you know?

Essay!!! :D
aigooism From: aigooism Date: August 4th, 2005 05:49 am (UTC) (Link)
Bill/Fleur is alright with me since it pisses Molly and Ginny off XD.

But yeah I prefer Bill with someone else though.
jazzbandmusic From: jazzbandmusic Date: August 4th, 2005 01:16 pm (UTC) (Link)
Oh I don't mind it, but I do think he goes better with say Harry! Even better he's with Fluer, but dumps her for Harry! lol! I'm sure those two together would annoy Molly and Ginny to no end!
11 comments or Leave a comment